Aruba

Aruba Networks offers a WLAN system that includes a network switch acting as the WLAN controller, and APs that are managed by the switch. When installing an Aruba network, you must first install the APs and WLAN. The initial reaction to an installation like this is often, "Where do you place the APs? Isn't that what a site survey is for?" The answer is to use a best-guess process based on user density and location (similar to the coffee cup survey discussed earlier), and to place enough APs to feel certain there will be more than enough RF coverage in the desired areas. This means using more APs than might be necessary based on user density. This overengineering enables you to cover any RF holes that might result from RF shadows and multipath interference.

During calibration, all APs and access monitors (AMs; AP type of device used only for monitoring and not for communication to clients) communicate with each other at the various data rates and different transmit power levels. This process allows the Aruba switch to build an RF-based map of the network topology, learning about environmental characteristics such as attenuation, interference, and reflection. When calibration is finished, Aruba's Wi-Fi switch automatically configures AP/AM mode of the APs, transmit power levels, and channel selection to minimize interference and maximize coverage and throughput.

Because such a system is not truly bullet proof and there is a high probability of RF holes, Aruba provides a feature called Coverage Hole Detection. Coverage Hole Detection looks for clients that have been unable to associate to any AP (not sure how this feature works, because the device is not associated to an AP and therefore the AP does not know the client is even there), or associating at low data rates or low signal strength. These symptoms indicate areas of a building where holes in RF coverage exist. When the system detects such coverage holes, the administrator is notified of the condition via the event log. At that point, the administrator must go into the facility and place another AP.

Cisco Assisted Survey Utility

The Cisco Assisted Site Survey tool is a cross between the automated survey and the manual survey. In most cases, there is a need to perform some initial testing at the site before using the WLAN manager site survey tool, and hence the name Assisted Site Survey. The tool is a part of the Wireless LAN Solution Engine (WLSE).

The first step is to determine the area (using the floor plan) that will cover the desired number of users. This must be done in the different types of areas where densities will vary, such as conference rooms, lunch rooms, and so on, because these require a higher number of APs to provide the ratio of users to APs specified in the design.

After determining that the cell size of a full-power AP, at the defined minimum data rate, is greater than needed to provide coverage for the maximum number of users for a single AP, you can use the floor plan to determine locations for the APs. Some areas (such as conference rooms) will use a smaller cell size to maintain the proper ratio of users to APs. After the AP locations have been determined, the installation must be done. After installing the APs, you can begin the assisted site survey.

The Cisco Assisted Site Survey tool requires the use of the Cisco WLSE on the network, and the survey is completed in three parts. The first part is an AP scan, which takes control of all APs and performs a scan by each AP, listening for all other APs. When this is completed, there is a mode (it is optional, but highly recommended) known as the client walkabout. This is where a Cisco client (or Cisco CE client) is walked throughout the facility, usually around the perimeter, and throughout the internal area. The client in turn reports back to WLSE regarding the signal levels it reads from the APs as it moves about.

In the final step, radio-management-assisted configuration, the WLSE uses the data information from the client walkabout and AP scan to adjust to the signal levels reported by the clients at each data point. WLSE then increases or decreases the transmit power of the AP to provide an adequate S/N ratio.

Clients in most applications are 3 feet to 4 feet off the floor and are generally subject to a good deal more attenuation than an AP. For this reason, the WLSE optional client walkabout mode will factor in the results of the survey data collected by the clients, providing a much more robust survey than one that uses the AP scan only. Another factor that is missed in an AP-scan-only type of utility is that the S/N ratio changes depending on the modulation type and data rate (and depending on the location in the facility and even within a single cell). The client walkabout takes this into account.